top of page

Why We've Always Made Music Together - Why Amateur Musicians Matter

Paula Taylor
6 days ago
3 min read

Today, the word "amateur" often infers a lack of experience or skill, but its original meaning had nothing to do with ability. The word comes from the Latin amator—"one who loves.” An amateur was someone who did something for the love of it. We believe that definition is still true.


Acoustic string players in a backyard jam at Meadowood Music

That simple definition describes most of the music ever made.

Long before concert halls, recording studios, radio stations, or streaming services, people made music together specifically because it brought them together. Around campfires, on front porches, in churches, at weddings, in village squares, and around family pianos, ordinary people sang and played—not as performers, but as participants.


This isn't just a romantic idea. Ethnomusicologists have long recognized that music is one of humanity's defining characteristics. Bruno Nettl (1930–2020) observed in The Origins of Music that every culture has found ways to make music, and that no culture of which we know lives without it. 

Every culture sings, creates and performs music, often dances, and passes musical traditions from one generation to the next. While musical structures vary, music-making itself appears to be a human universal. That suggests music serves a purpose much deeper than entertainment.


Researchers from fields including anthropology, psychology, neuroscience, and evolutionary biology increasingly believe that making music together helped strengthen early human communities (sources below). Shared music encourages cooperation, reinforces social bonds, preserves stories, celebrates important milestones, and expresses emotions that words alone sometimes cannot capture. Perhaps that's why music has survived every civilization that has ever existed.


Today we often think of music as something we consume. We stream it, purchase tickets to hear it, or listen while driving or working. There is certainly nothing wrong with enjoying great performers. But for thousands of years, music wasn't something people watched. It was something they did. Every family gathering with a guitar, every church choir, every community band, every jam session, every parent singing a lullaby, every child taking music lessons continues a tradition as old as humanity itself.


Professional musicians inspire us. They expand what is artistically possible. But amateur musicians keep music where it has always belonged—woven into everyday life rather than confined to the concert stage. 


We believe this is a profound truth. In the first draft of Meadowood's business plan in 1995—and in every revision over the past thirty years—we've included this simple vision statement:

  • Virtuoso performances are breathtaking, but shouldn't replace the music that people make themselves and share with others.

We believe that's why learning an instrument is about more than acquiring a skill. It's about joining one of humanity's oldest conversations.


At our jam sessions and open mics we've hosted for decades, we see people who might not otherwise meet form bonds: a Vietnam Vet living on disability sitting next to a renowned eye surgeon who drove to the jam in a car that cost more than the Vet’s home, eight- and ten-year-old children playing with an octogenarian retired engineer, political conservatives sitting next to political progressives, clerics, atheists and agnostics belting out a traditional Gospel tune. Income, education, age, politics, and religion all matter in some parts of life. In a circle of musicians, however, they matter a little less.


Perhaps one reason music has endured throughout human history is that it asks us to see a Gestalt, to see that the whole is greater than the sum of the parts, to take a role that supports the whole. A choir, string quartet, band, or orchestra depends on individuals working toward a common purpose. A jam session succeeds because musicians listen as carefully as they play. These are habits that healthy communities need as much as good music does.

Perhaps that's why humans have always made music together. Music teaches lessons that healthy communities continually need to relearn. We listen before we respond. We contribute without overwhelming others. We leave room for another voice. Music doesn't require us to become the same person. It simply invites us to become part of the same song


_____

  • Dissanayake, Ellen. "Antecedents of the Temporal Arts in Early Mother–Infant Interaction." In The Origins of Music. MIT Press, 2000.

  • Dunbar, Robin I. M., Jacques Launay, Eiluned Pearce, et al. "Performance of Music Elevates Pain Threshold and Positive Affect: Implications for the Evolutionary Function of Music." Evolutionary Psychology 10, no. 4 (2012): 688–702.

  • Dunbar, Robin I. M. How Religion Evolved: And Why It Endures. Oxford University Press, 2022.

  • Honing, Henkjan, ed. The Origins of Musicality. MIT Press, 2018.

  • Jordania, Joseph. Why Do People Sing? Music in Human Evolution. Logos, 2011.

  • Wallin, Nils L., Björn Merker, and Steven Brown, eds. The Origins of Music. MIT Press, 2000.

These authors support our understanding that collective music-making strengthened cooperation, social cohesion, and resilience in early human communities, and make us believe that it has the same power in contemporary communities.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page